![]() |
Scene at the Signing of the Constitution of the United States Howard Chandler Christy (PD) |
Henry Knox, bookseller, self-educated artillerist, the fellow who led the effort to drag cannon down from Fort Ticonderoga to drive the British from Boston. I mean that's what I knew about him. Now, having read the book, I know he was so much more.
Friend , and trusted advisor, to George Washington and Nathanael Greene, a Rhode Islander whose southern campaign during the Revolution (which is described once removed in the most excellent The Swamp Fox: How Francis Marion Saved the American Revolution by John Oller, which I finished a week ago, also a gift from John Blackshoe) had few victories but eventually drove the ragged British army under Cornwallis north to Virginia, where they were eventually defeated at Yorktown. (I had no idea that the war continued on for some time after that, ah, the deficiencies of a public education.)
Knox was quite a guy, I highly recommend both of the aforementioned volumes (available in multiple places but also Amazon).
Now this post isn't so much a book report as it is a post about perspective.
1a : a mental view or prospect
b : a visible scene
2a : the interrelation in which a subject or its parts are mentally viewed
b : the capacity to view things in their true relations or relative importance
3 : the appearance to the eye of objects in respect to their relative distance and positions
4a : the technique or process of representing on a plane or curved surface the spatial relation of objects as they might appear to the eye
b : a picture in perspective
My point being that long after Knox and Marion lived, books were written about them by folks who had the longer perspective of the events which Knox and Marion lived through than folks did at the time.
Historians know that to judge an event in its immediate aftermath as to its importance or its meaning is foolhardy at best. Ofttimes we have no idea of the effects of an event until well after it takes place.
Take, for instance, the current state of affairs in our fair nation. Now I hear things every day from both sides of the aisle, so to speak. I have friends and relatives who are on either side of any given issue. They ask me for my take on these things, I always say the same thing ...
"It's too soon to tell if this is good or bad. I'm taking a wait and see approach."
Now that viewpoint can be frustrating to some. I know people in government service who have labored long and faithfully there. They have done their best, they have worked damned hard, often in times of shifting priorities and uncertain funding. They do the best they can and right now many of them are quite nervous at what's coming tomorrow, or the next day.
The way DOGE has gone about firing people has many in fear for their livelihoods. Many undeservedly so. Many of the people who visit here have a very low opinion of Washington DC. Some folks on the Book of Faces enjoy describing it as "a wretched hive of scum and villainy," most of whom probably have very little idea of how things work (or don't) in our nation's capital.
The dust hasn't settled yet, the extremes on both sides are behaving like knuckleheads, as so aptly put by Peter Grant over at Bayou Renaissance Man. Where will it end?
I have no idea, but then again, I take the long view of things, or try to. I also fully believe that God is in charge.
But for now, I would advise all and sundry to buckle up, it's going to be a bumpy ride. And while you're at it ...
Don't be a knucklehead.
Often wisdom is keeping your mouth shut. Why did it take so many decades for me to learn the lesson my Dad tried to drive home when I was a lad.
ReplyDeleteBut it is hard with the internet before you a keyboard at the ready just to WAIT a Day or so to get Paul Harvys "The REST of the story" before commenting.
I need to remind myself, constantly, of Samuel Clemens' remark " It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt."
DeleteConstantly.
the way A remembers it;
ReplyDeletethe way B remembers it;
what really happened.
And every flavor in between.
DeleteI watch the current events with hope for my nation, positive things are happening and then again negative things are happening. It is going to take awhile to see if the Constitution is still guiding things or if the courts/bureaucracy have won.
ReplyDeleteThe Dept of Education is an example. Education is not mentioned in the Constitution so according to the 10th Amendment that should be a State thing, but it's not. Will the Dept of Education be allowed to go away or will it and it's $240+billion budget keep on doing what ever it is that it does? Time will tell...
Kids are not being educated in many places and teachers aren't getting paid more, yet the number of school administrators (and their salaries) seem to increase by leaps and bounds.
DeletePart if the issue with schools and the DoE is that the increased need by the schools to provide information to the DoE means that admin pukes increase in number. And, of course, upper level administrators breed like rats.
DeleteYou see the same thing in medical practices. The increase in admin personnel due to Medicare and Medicaid documentation requirements means that more and more employees fill up a practice or a hospital while the actual workers are being cut to the bone, because if you don't cross every 'T' and dot every 'I' then you don't get government reimbursement.
Ah yes, the ubiquitous government paperwork.
DeleteArguably at least one generation, maybe two, need to pass to get a larger and fuller of impact. Alexander and Julius Caesar both thought they were building empires for themselves; neither really got to "enjoy" them.
ReplyDeleteNot sure what Caesar thought he was building, was he "saving the republic" (as has been claimed by some) or was he seeking power for power's sake. I don't think Alexander really thought things through to their logical conclusion.
DeleteBut yes, it takes at least a generation.
Social Media has given everyone the chance to comment NOW, who needs patience? Wait for the facts? Well....yes.....darn good advice Sarge. Mr. Grant has some thoughtful posts over on his blog and being retired there is time to peruse a few blogs out there. Doggone it Sarge, now there's a couple more books to go looking for............:)
ReplyDeleteSocial media, it was all fun and games until the fanatics took over.
DeleteYou must love the book and series "Connections" by James Burke. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(British_TV_series) I believe all episodes can be found on YouTube. Also by him, "The Day The Universe Changed" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Day_the_Universe_Changed
ReplyDeleteMany of our issues today can be laid on the shoulders of well meaning people. My wife says that the most damning phrase in the English language is 'He Mean Well," i.e. he wants to do good, and wants what is good for people, but he hasn't a clue about people, life, the universe, and everything, and so doesn't recognize the long term consequences of his actions/policies.
The differences in people in this country can be summed up in "We can/must make it better" and "Leave me and mine alone!". The problem with the former is that they nearly always want to impose their version of " better" on the latter group as well as having the latter pay the bill for better.
DeleteGotta say, Sarge all of the knuckleheads I've seen - and I pay attention, probably too much attention - have overwhelmingly been from one side.
Commentary off.
Now about those books. The people who committed treason against the Crown and gave us our Republic are a special group; we always should learn as much as we can about them. Henry Knox is a particular favorite of mine; being an Artilleryman. The best smartest man I ever knew - my Father - was also a "self taught" Artilleryman.
Boat Guy
Joe - Never heard of that series until today. Looks like it's worth a look. The road to Hell is paved with good intentions.
DeleteBG - I won't argue with that proposition. Sounds logical to me.
DeleteAkin to "must make it better" is "We must do something NOW!!!" as opposed to "Let us sit down and think this over".
DeleteImmediacy seems to take precedence over necessity.
DeleteGlad my library contributions fell on a fertile mind! Knox and Marion are but two brave men to whom we owe our present freedoms. There are many others, and none of us will ever learn about all of them, but we certainly should learn about more of them than will be revealed in our public skools these days.
ReplyDeleteBook buying tip for everyone- ABEbooks.com is a great source, a compilation of the offerings of thousands of booksellers, from tiny to the big players. Good search tool, and ability to sort by price low to high (if you are a cheapskate like me), and most places include free shipping, and most I buy are under $10. Load your cart up and one click orders everything at one time, so it is not YOU doing the work to place individual orders all over the world, the ABEbooks folks make all that happen. (They also offer "print on demand" copies of older works in the public domain, coming from India which are pretty good, and incredibly cheap options for otherwise hard to find tomes.)
Books are great, but my personal fascination is with tangible artifacts. A "collector of stuff" has physical touchstones as reminders of the past. Some antiquarians are inspired and worship the stuff (or what it represents), and others see only "stuff" and any meaning remains invisible to them. In my case, new "stuff" invariably leads to more books to learn more. My bookshelves runneth over, to my wife's dismay and they begin to accrete in the bedroom and public spaces until she forces me to prune the stacks.
In this case Sarge was the recipient of some of my excess, and I am delighted he found at least two of the stack worthwhile.
John Blackshoe
Getting rid of a book is difficult, as I found out when I went from a proper house to an RV.
DeleteWell done Sir!
JB - That is indeed an excellent source for books!
DeleteRob - I have a very hard time getting rid of a book. I've done it precisely once. That was on Okinawa where I'd found a science fiction/swords & sorcery novel which turned out to be: misogynistic, racist, and what's more, extremely poorly written. That book went into the nearest trash receptacle after about fifty pages. I do not regret throwing that thing out.
DeleteALIBRIS, and Thrift Books are pretty good, too.
DeleteOkay.
DeleteKnox is my man! Love that guy. What a life story. From Nerd to Hero. What WWI Germans would call a gifted amateur.
ReplyDeleteAs to events unfolding, yeah, gotta wait at least 72 hours to see what's actually happening. But the media doesn't like that. They have to rush to judgement in order to either be first to report or be first to manipulate.
We have seen, in a month and a half, events moving so fast and so increased in amount that it's very hard for outsiders (and many swamp dwellers) to actually understand what's happening. Crazy amounts of things. And because we are outside of the decision loop, we can't see what's going on.
Like the wet fart release of the Epstein files by AG Bondi. People were calling it a total flop and proof that Bondi is a swamp dweller. But what if Bondi released the minimal intel that she had in order to force the NY FBI office to cough up stuff it was holding, while also setting up the leaders of said office to be fired for cause, that being withholding a lawful order by the FBI head.
Precisely, we don't know the moves being made behind the scenes nor what the end game is. Patience is required here.
DeleteI kind of see 'now' as an Oliver Cromwell kind of moment but without the bloodshed. I have witnessed the very best and the very worst of what the military offers and what is good is very good and what is bad destroys all vestiges wrought by the good. It is the same with the former civil service but much worse. This would be sort of like that 'refreshed with the blood of patriots' except this time we're throwing the blood we can best spare and to be perfectly honest, nobody will miss it and in 10 years you will never know it happened.
ReplyDeleteIn your reading of the time shortly after the founding did you ever see a single man of that time that thought that the State had a higher calling on the citizen and the citizen's money and property than the Citizen did? I didn't. In all my reading the Government supported itself to the extent it was required by only taking that which was the government's to take and not running around screwing every citizen for every nickle. They would find the idea abhorrent and did.
It is an Oliver Cromwell moment, I like the analogy.
Delete