Thursday, March 31, 2022

Guest Post - Ukraine: The View from Poland, Day 33

Ukrainian civilians posing in front of what remains of the 4th Guards Tank Division in Trostyanets, Sumy
(Source)
Hello, this is Paweł from Ewok Report, your friendly Empire-bashing critter from forests of Eastern Endor... erm, Europe.

Ahem.

Stalemate. This is best encapsulated by newest political joke in Moscow - 

"Welcome to <insert number here- as I write it is 33rd> day of the three-day special military action to capture Kiev."

So what events changed since last week?

First:

http://cdrsalamander.blogspot.com/2022/03/scratch-one-russian-navy-alligator-lst.html

https://twitter.com/COUPSURE/status/1506969662789140480

Leave it to Salamander to discuss technical know-how of LST being hit and sunk in port. 

Apparently Russians telegraphed in own TV the news reel of ships offloading at the pier,  allowing UKR OSINT to pinpoint place to strike. In the days of Google street view posting any video online - or in TV - pretty much broadcasts to the enemies  "target me!"

An important thing seems to be leaked from the talks between warring sides:

https://www.politico.eu/article/ukraine-neutral-status-russia-peace-agreement-volodymyr-zelenskyy/

So, the NATO membership is off the table finally, but I think for Russia that was not the real problem. They wanted Ukraine a colony, a protectorate, not independent nation. So NATO membership was just a solidifying of the first problem, the independent and democratic Ukraine.

https://www.politico.eu/article/survivor-story-darkest-hell-ukraine-mariupol/

Meanwhile, Russians unleashed their worst indiscriminate fires on Mariupol, place they seem most close to capturing out of major cities, and crucial component of land bridge to Crimea.

Satellite images show grim picture indeed:

https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/cpsprodpb/A72A/production/_123949724_mariupol_residential_2_640x2-nc.png

This has even prompted some European leaders to throw an idea of evacuation effort:

https://www.politico.eu/article/macron-france-spearhead-exceptional-operation-evacuate-mariupol/

I am not sure if it will come to anything though with Russians owning the waters around the port. This would also likely risk escalation into open exchange of blows with NATO ships...

Meanwhile war has impacted oil market - not that kind of oil...

https://www.politico.eu/article/belgiums-frites-makers-feel-the-heat-as-ukraines-sunflower-oil-stops-flowing/

Here is when I report from first hand witness perspective, working at supermarket in Poland near German border I had number of German clients buying large numbers of oil bottles in typical panic buyer mode...

Add this oil global market shortage to the grain shortage and it is even worse hunger crisis in the making. With animal fats no sell on many markets due to religious reasons (remember the Sepoy mutiny, anyone?) this takes another important source of nutrients into scarcity.

And war makes for strange bedfellows - well not that strange considering Germany has been helping Israel by building them submarines, for example , for years - and those subs are crucial component of Israeli deterrence, likely housing nuclear cruise missiles...

https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-in-preliminary-discussions-to-buy-israeli-air-defense-system/

Last but not least, the elephant - or rather donkey - in the room:

https://www.politico.com/news/2022/03/26/biden-putin-poland-speech-00020671

Biden lands for a short visit, and delivers what was sad, sad attempt to imitate Kennedy or Reagan of the past.

Lots of platitudes, occasional faux pas - and not much of substance. I expected announcement of heavy brigade, or better division permanently stationed in Poland, best coupled with a fighter wing... Alas, nope. All of you who don't like Biden, feel free to make a piñata of him, but as with military, you go to war with president you have.

At least he didn't get into direct shooting war with Russia, so that's a bonus.

Because, someone had a very good observation here:

https://warontherocks.com/2022/03/a-proxy-war-in-ukraine-is-the-worst-possible-outcome-except-for-all-the-others/

Russian walkover would be invitation for more conquest. Direct war would be risking nuclear escalation with only nation of Earth capable of wiping out the USA.  What is left is a messy solution that costs most the people of Ukraine, but is after eliminating worst options only course left...

See ya (hopefully) next week.

I am betting case of our best local beer that it will be 7 more days added to that joke I mentioned earlier.

Any takers?

Paweł aka Ewok

P.S.

Moving picture is worth million words:


While this particular T-72 escaped death (ERA¹ tiles worked or missile malfunctioned), what is evident from the vid is total lack of infantry supporting the tank.

"We never learn" - Russian army , Berlin 45, Budapest 56, Grozny 95, Ukraine 22

Also, newest leaks from diplomatic talks indicate Russians are declaring retreat in Kyiv and Czermihiv areas "as a token of goodwill," but presumably only to reinforce South Eastern front somewhere along the Donbas front.




11 comments:

  1. Ah, good article. To be fair to Biden, he does not want a two front war. And I fear that the Chinese are watching about, what works. Just as reports of the same training and watching are reported in India, Malaysia and Australia.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "Ewok from the jungle planet"... Thank you Pawel. I now have a number of competing mental images about you, although of them which make me smile.

    What remains (fortunately) shocking to me is what seems to be significant mis-steps in logistics, which (as far as I am aware) no-one had pegged for the Russians. Either everyone's intelligence gathering operations were really that off base or it was a buried problem that not even the Russians knew they had (until they did). What I am hoping for and yet fearful of is that lots of people are watching - and learning - from their mistakes (looking at you, China).

    The worldwide impact on food and fuel is real and every day this goes on, it gets more profound. At some point - at least for the food - we will pass the point of no return in that after a certain, there simply will be no more planting and then, like the supply chain issue, we will simply be behind the curve for the foreseeable future. Curious as you reference German customers - are these customers crossing the border from Germany to shop? That would be pretty significant indeed.

    As always, thank you for the update and stay safe.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Germans come shopping here all the time, capitalizing on price differences between countries. What was remarkable this time was focus on frying oil and large quantities.

      Delete
  3. Very good post Pawel, some interesting links there although my PC doesn't like Politico. With that T-72 vid less shouting and more aiming, like rear deck perhaps. But it's easy to be critical when sitting in a warm, intact house.

    ReplyDelete
  4. re: NLAWS

    Appears fired inside minimum arm distance. No arm, no boom. Should have aimed at top of deck above motor...if you shoot from that close.

    RAS

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Most probable explanation, definitely. too close to arm, no boom.

      Delete
    2. Yes, but....I suspect laundry service was required for the Russian crew's underwear. Just saying.

      Delete
  5. Regarding Israel and Germany, Germany is expanding Israel's surface fleet with some frigates with decent guns on them.

    As to the rest, sounds like the material loss of the Russian army is incredible. Wonder when they will reach unreplacable levels?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well done, Paweł. I look forward to the next installment. Hopefully it will tell the tale of the end of this war.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I wonder if the pulling back is only for retrograde, to sleep and resupply.

    ReplyDelete

Just be polite... that's all I ask. (For Buck)
Can't be nice, go somewhere else...

NOTE: Comments on posts over 5 days old go into moderation, automatically.