Friday, November 29, 2024

The Glory and Fall of the Commonwealth - part 1

Kraków Militia, a local guard formation in the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth during the 16th and 17th centuries
Fragment of the 
Rulonu polskiego
Balthasar Gebhardt, ca. 1605, gouache on parchment (PD)
In the 1500s and 1600s, if you look upon the map of Eastern Europe you notice a giant state, stretching from Baltic to almost Black Sea, and from Poznan (Posen) to Smolensk on the road to Moscow.

But by 1800s if you look upon same map, you will see that state not merely shrinking or changing borders, but disappearing entirely, as if swallowed by surrounding powers.

How did it come to pass?

Roots of the Polish-Lithuanian state emerged in late 1300s, when both countries threatened by aggressive policies of the Teutonic Order state in Prussia formed alliance, cemented by marriage of Lithuanian Grand Duke Jogaila (in Polish, known as Jagiełło) to Polish King (sic!) Jadwiga (tl;dr - Polish nobility accepted female King due to dynastic reasons).

Added bonus for the sides was Christianization of Lithuania. Lithuania gained entry into then exclusive family of european Christian nations, and deprived Teutons of their claimed reason for war, namely conversion by fire and sword. Poland gained respect as the ones who did succeed with diplomacy where Teutons failed with sword.

Results were soon visible, with the alliance dealing the Teutonic Order crippling defeat in the Battle of Grunwald aka Tannenberg in 1410. I will deal with this battle as first of the dramas little heard of, or learned today in the West.

Teutonic order fielded what by 1400s standards was top tech modern military - featuring mercenary English longbowmen, elite knight cavalry, and even some primitive canons.

Aided by extremely efficient administration by medieval standards (all posts were nominated by the Order itself, not hereditary) Order was wealthy enough to afford it, and dealt crushing blow after another to all enemies - subjugating Prussian pagans within less than century 1226-1283, taking Gdansk aka Danzig from Poland in 1308 in an act of betrayal straight out of Game of Thrones - Poles hired Teutonic knights to help fend off Brandenburgian raid, only for the Teutons to turn on their allies, slaughter Polish crew and many civilians, and take the city for themselves, and expanding into Lithuania.

Eventually, things came to decisive blows in 1409 , when Teutonic Order declared war on the alliance, hoping to crush them before they grow too powerful.

After some time of maneuvering and armistices, the armies came to blows in the heart of the Prussian domain, on fields between the villages of Grunwald and Tannenberg, hence the names for the battle.

Polish army featured mostly similarly equipped knights to the Order, with some peasant levies thrown in for good measure. Lithuanian side was mostly light cavalry, Mongol style, and even featuring some actual Mongol mercenaries.

There were even some Czech mercenaries on Polish side, led by none other than future Hussite leader Jan Žižka.

The battle was chronicled pretty accurately by contemporary historians. It seems that initially Teutons gained advantage by routing Lithuanians - or possibly failing prey to the feigned retreat. Eventually, though , Lithuanian forces that fled - or feigned flight - returned to the fray and helped encircle the Teutonic army, ending with massive defeat. Out of 200 "white cloaks", the full brothers of the order, only 70 escaped. Only the almost unconquerable castle of Malbork aka Marienburg saved the Order from total defeat.

Here are some sources:
  • Battle of Grunwald (Wikipedia)
  • Battle of Grunwald (Britannica)
  • Battle of Grunwald (The Collector)
  • Battle of Grunwald (YouTube) (Video taken from 1960 cinema epic "Knights of the Cross" based on historic novel, so take with more than a pinch of salt - but still more precise medieval warfare depiction than any todays CGI wonders ...)


Next episode: The Jagiellon dynasty, 13 years war , and establishment of electionary monarchy.




Editor's Note: I only did minimal editing of the post. Paweł's English is quite good and I wanted this to be in his words and not do some hacked up editing of my own. I'm betting most of you don't speak Polish, so don't be too critical of Paweł's English.

17 comments:

  1. Alliances, boarders and names of places changes as new stronger forces come in.

    Geography helps or hinders that creation-destruction cycle as like the Swiss mountains being easily defended and they stood neutral through WW2.

    Seems to be the basics of history. Mao might have been correct that power comes from the barrel of a gun.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have a lot of respect for a non-native-English speaker writing in his second language for an international crowd of English speakers (perhaps even other non-native English speakers who visit this blog). Not only was it coherent, but its subject, which is rarely known outside of Eastern Europe, intrigued me. I look forward to stories based on this history or more actual history on the subject.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent abstract. About a third of the way in I was thinking that it was a guest post by Pawel because of some quirks in grammar.

    The YouTube clip, in a bit of serendipity, I had watched several months ago. I don't recall why, but I was looking for " Bogoroditsa," possibly wanting to find the Slavonic spelling and orthography, and it was one of several that showed up with that hymn.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I just remembered the convoluted path I took to that video. In the "Ring of Fire" series the mild disagreement between Gustavus Adolphus and the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth is mentioned, so I had to look up the Polish-Lithuanian state, and one article made mention of "Polish Battle Hymn," which diverted me to "Bogurodzica."

      Re: ignorant monoglot Americans - It always amazes me when I'm in a discussion, either online or in person, and someone from Europe (usually) starts off with , "Excuse my poor English, it's not my native language." Right, you're fluent in 5 languages and conversant in 3 more, and you're apologizing to monoglot Americans that your English isn't perfectly idiomatic American English?

      I watch quite a few cooking videos, mostly Instagram reels, in Russian and Ukrainian (similar but not quite the same), and some Aberbaizhani on Youtube. I recently started following a Polish guy on. I'll ask, "Please help this dumb monoglot American, will you post the cooking times in English? " Especially important on something like his pork loin version of basturma - dry cured loin, served in wafer thin slices.

      Delete
    2. "ignorant monoglot Americans"... for most of my life I could travel from one corner of my country to the other, literally thousands & thousand of miles, and never run into anyone not speaking my language. Knowing a different language was not needed.

      Delete
    3. Exactly. No, "Well, I'm off at 7 a.m, to have breakfast in France, lunch in Germany, a quick shopping trip to Italy. I'll be home for dinner. " More like, "I'll leave San Diego at 7 a.m. and should make it to Eureka by sundown." Texas is even worse.

      Delete
  4. Thank you all for reading. Work is gonna get busy before Christmas, as people seem to go out of their minds on shopping sprees , but I will attempt to write more of the series soon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Lithuania is where my mom's parents came from in the early 1900s, that grandpa passed before I was born and I saw my grandma twice in my life. I remember her trying to teach me some Lithuanian words...
    This is good stuff as I know nothing about the history from that part of the world!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I never criticize anyone's speech or writing when it comes to English. It's a challenging enough language for Brits, the Irish and Americans, with its rules then aren't really rules all the time, and multiple pronunciations of words that look and read the same. And they speak and right my language far better than I write theirs, which is not at all. Nice post Pawel.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A couple dictation typos in there, shows that not even blogger knows English very well!

      Delete
    2. In defense of English, although it is challenging, it can also be mercilessly butchered, misused and mispronounced, but the meaning of the speaker or writer usually comes through. I consider that the international scientific language is heavily accented broken English.

      Delete
    3. That's a nice way of putting it.

      Delete
  7. Most enlightening.

    And a good reminder why we should not be too eager to waste our own borrowed treasure and potentially the blood of our children to preserve borders on a map drawn less than a century ago. Let those with land and skin in the fight arrive at a conclusion they can (or must) live with. We can be happy or sad at the outcome, but it is foolish to think we can impose a settlement that will last forever.
    JB

    ReplyDelete
  8. Nicely done, Paweł. Can't wait for the rest of the story! (When you can, no pressure.)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Pawel, we actually studied those battles in the Army’s School for Advanced Military Studies, ( the Jedi Knights of the Gulf War went there). Nice to hear a “local” expert. Excelent summary. Thanks
    juvat

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks Pawel! I suspect for a lot of Americans, the Commonwealth is a pretty obscure piece of history - I mostly know only of the mid-17th Century related to Jan Sobieski, and that in relation to the Siege of Vienna in A.D. 1683.

    ReplyDelete

Just be polite... that's all I ask. (For Buck)
Can't be nice, go somewhere else...

NOTE: Comments on posts over 5 days old go into moderation, automatically.